Robust and Verifiable Proportionality Axioms for Multiwinner Voting

31^st October 2023, 13:00 Ashton Lecture Theatre
Dr. Markus Brill
Department of Computer Science, University of Warwick

Abstract

When selecting a subset of candidates (a so-called committee) based on the preferences of voters, proportional representation is often a major desideratum. When going beyond simplistic models such as party-list or district-based elections, it is surprisingly challenging to capture proportionality formally. As a consequence, the literature has produced numerous competing criteria of when a selected committee qualifies as proportional. Two of the most prominent notions are Dummett's proportionality for solid coalitions (PSC) and Aziz et al.'s extended justified representation (EJR). Both guarantee proportional representation to groups of voters who have very similar preferences; such groups are referred to as solid coalitions by Dummett and as cohesive groups by Aziz et al. However, these notions lose their bite when groups are only almost solid or almost cohesive.

In this paper, we propose proportionality axioms that are more robust: they guarantee representation also to groups that do not qualify as solid or cohesive. Further, our novel axioms can be easily verified: Given a committee, we can check in polynomial time whether it satisfies the axiom or not. This is in contrast to many established notions like EJR, for which the corresponding verification problem is known to be intractable.

In the setting with approval preferences, we propose a robust and verifiable variant of EJR and a simply greedy procedure to compute committees satisfying it. In the setting with ranked preferences, we propose a robust variant PSC, which can be efficiently verified even for general weak preferences. In the special case of strict preferences, our notion is the first known satisfiable proportionality axiom that is violated by the Single Transferable Vote (STV). We also discuss implications of our results for participatory budgeting, querying procedures, and to the notion of proportionality degree.

Joint work with Jannik Peters.

Biography

Markus Brill is an associate professor of computer science at the University of Warwick. Before that, he was leading the Emmy Noether Research Group “Foundations of Interactive Democracy” at TU Berlin. He has spent one year as a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Oxford, and two years as a postdoctoral researcher at Duke University. He obtained a PhD in Computer Science from TU Munich in 2012.

Additional Materials

• https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.01989